How Mel Stottlemyre's ERA Compares to Similar Players

Mel Stottlemyre posted a career ERA of 2.97, well below the starting pitcher average of 3.87 — a mark that ranked among the best of his era. His strongest ERA season came in 1964, posting 2.06, well below the starting pitcher average of 3.57 that year. The highest point came in 1966 at 3.8, near the starting pitcher average of 3.54 that year. Production slipped through the final seasons. The figure moved from 3.22 in 1972 to 3.07 in 1973 and 3.58 in 1974. The decline marked the closing chapter of the career. Some season-to-season variance runs through the career line, but the career average remained well above league norms across 11 seasons.

Mel Stottlemyre Lifetime ERA and Similar Stats

Stats similar to ERA for Mel Stottlemyre
Mel Stottlemyre
ERA
Mel Stottlemyre
Component ERA
Mel Stottlemyre
Defense Independent ERA
Career2.973.063.85
Season Avg.2.973.063.85
162 Game Avg.2.973.063.85
More InfoSee MoreSee MoreSee More

Mel Stottlemyre ERA Per Season

Mel Stottlemyre's ERA for each season of his MLB career, plotted against that year's league average. Switch between comparisons — American League, Hall of Fame, SP, North America, or players born in the same country — to see how he stacked up year by year.
Mel Stottlemyre ERA per season line chart

Mel Stottlemyre ERA by Team

Mel Stottlemyre's career ERA totals broken down by each team he played for, ordered by when he first joined that team.
Mel Stottlemyre career ERA by team bar chart

Mel Stottlemyre ERA Year-Over-Year Change

A waterfall chart tracking how Mel Stottlemyre's career ERA shifted from season to season. Each bar represents the change added to his career total that year, making peak and decline phases easy to spot.
Mel Stottlemyre ERA year-over-year waterfall chart

Mel Stottlemyre ERA Distribution vs. Comparable Players

Each box summarizes Mel Stottlemyre's seasonal ERA alongside a selected comparison group across all seasons he played. The box covers the middle 50% of seasons, the center line is the median, and the whiskers extend to the min and max. A tighter box means more consistency; a higher median means more output. Use the selector to switch comparison groups.
Mel Stottlemyre ERA distribution box chart versus comparable players

Mel Stottlemyre ERA — Season-by-Season Breakdown

Every season of Mel Stottlemyre's MLB career with ERA alongside league, Hall of Fame, positional, birth region, and country-of-birth averages for that year. Career totals include sum, average, min, max, and median.

Note: A dash (—) means no qualifying players existed in that comparison group for that season. Most commonly this happens for the Hall of Fame group.
Mel Stottlemyre ERA season-by-season breakdown table