Elmer Jacobs vs. Batters

Have you ever wondered how Elmer Jacobs matches up against MLB batters? Select a player from the list of popular matchups or browse the list of all players. Review the matchup and decide who you think is best!

Select a player from the list below

 Philadelphia Phillies
Hall of Fame tag for Pete Alexander
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 New York Giants
 Brooklyn Tip-Tops
 New York Giants
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Philadelphia Phillies
Hall of Fame tag for Dave Bancroft
 Chicago Cubs
 Boston Braves
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 St. Louis Cardinals
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Philadelphia Athletics
Hall of Fame tag for Charles Bender
 Cincinnati Reds
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Philadelphia Athletics
 Chicago White Sox
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Washington Senators
 Detroit Tigers
 Boston Braves
 Cincinnati Reds
 Philadelphia Athletics
 New York Yankees
 St. Louis Cardinals
Hall of Fame tag for Jim Bottomley
 Cincinnati Reds
 St. Louis Browns
 Boston Braves
 New York Giants
 Cleveland Guardians
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Pittsburgh Pirates
Hall of Fame tag for Max Carey
 Boston Red Sox
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Cincinnati Reds
 New York Yankees
 Chicago Cubs
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Detroit Tigers
Hall of Fame tag for Ty Cobb
 Philadelphia Athletics
Hall of Fame tag for Mickey Cochrane
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Boston Braves
 Philadelphia Athletics
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Cincinnati Reds
 Boston Braves
 New York Giants
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Chicago Cubs
Hall of Fame tag for Kiki Cuyler
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Chicago Cubs
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Cincinnati Reds
 Philadelphia Phillies
 New York Giants
 Cincinnati Reds
 Cincinnati Reds
 Chicago Cubs
 Chicago Cubs
Hall of Fame tag for Johnny Evers
 Boston Braves
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Boston Braves
 Chicago Cubs
 Boston Red Sox
 New York Giants
 Cleveland Guardians
 Cincinnati Reds
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 St. Louis Cardinals
Hall of Fame tag for Frankie Frisch
 Boston Braves
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Chicago Cubs
 Washington Senators
Hall of Fame tag for Goose Goslin
 Boston Braves
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Chicago Cubs
 Cincinnati Reds
 Philadelphia Athletics
 Cincinnati Reds
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Washington Senators
Hall of Fame tag for Bucky Harris
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Chicago Cubs
 Detroit Tigers
Hall of Fame tag for Harry Heilmann
 Chicago Cubs
 Philadelphia Phillies
 New York Giants
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Boston Braves
 Chicago Cubs
 St. Louis Cardinals
Hall of Fame tag for Rogers Hornsby
 St. Louis Cardinals
Hall of Fame tag for Miller Huggins
 New York Giants
Hall of Fame tag for Travis Jackson
 St. Louis Browns
 Cleveland Guardians
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Washington Senators
 New York Giants
 New York Giants
Hall of Fame tag for George Kelly
 Boston Braves
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Philadelphia Phillies
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Cincinnati Reds
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Buffalo Blues
 Philadelphia Phillies
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Boston Braves
 Washington Senators
Hall of Fame tag for Heinie Manush
 Boston Braves
Hall of Fame tag for Rabbit Maranville
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Chicago Cubs
 Chicago Cubs
 New York Giants
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Philadelphia Athletics
 Pittsburgh Pirates
Hall of Fame tag for Bill McKechnie
 St. Louis Browns
 St. Louis Cardinals
 New York Giants
 New York Giants
 New York Giants
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Cincinnati Reds
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Chicago White Sox
 New York Giants
 Washington Senators
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Cincinnati Reds
 New York Giants
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Boston Braves
 Chicago Cubs
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Boston Braves
 St. Louis Browns
 Kansas City Packers
 Boston Braves
 Philadelphia Phillies
 St. Louis Cardinals
 New York Giants
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Boston Braves
 Cincinnati Reds
 Boston Braves
 Boston Braves
 Cincinnati Reds
 Boston Braves
 Boston Red Sox
 Boston Red Sox
 Boston Braves
 Washington Senators
Hall of Fame tag for Sam Rice
 Boston Braves
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Cincinnati Reds
Hall of Fame tag for Eppa Rixey
 New York Giants
 Boston Red Sox
 Cincinnati Reds
Hall of Fame tag for Edd Roush
 Boston Braves
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Chicago Cubs
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Chicago Cubs
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Cleveland Guardians
Hall of Fame tag for Joe Sewell
 Cleveland Guardians
 Boston Red Sox
 Boston Braves
 Detroit Tigers
 St. Louis Browns
 New York Giants
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Boston Braves
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Boston Braves
 New York Giants
 New York Giants
 Boston Braves
Hall of Fame tag for Billy Southworth
 Cleveland Guardians
Hall of Fame tag for Tris Speaker
 Brooklyn Dodgers
Hall of Fame tag for Casey Stengel
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Detroit Tigers
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 New York Giants
Hall of Fame tag for Bill Terry
 Chicago Cubs
 New York Giants
 New York Giants
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Boston Red Sox
 Cincinnati Reds
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Boston Braves
 Pittsburgh Pirates
Hall of Fame tag for Pie Traynor
 Boston Braves
 Chicago Cubs
 Cincinnati Reds
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Detroit Tigers
 Brooklyn Dodgers
 Brooklyn Dodgers
Hall of Fame tag for Zack Wheat
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Boston Braves
 Philadelphia Phillies
 St. Louis Cardinals
 Chicago Whales
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Boston Braves
 Philadelphia Phillies
 Cincinnati Reds
 New York Yankees
 Chicago Cubs
 Pittsburgh Pirates
 Philadelphia Phillies
 New York Giants
Hall of Fame tag for Ross Youngs
 Chicago White Sox
 Chicago Cubs