Ed McDonough vs. Herman Roth — Career Comparison

Ed McDonough
Lost GenerationIllinoisThrows RightBats RightNorth AmericaPhiladelphia PhilliesNational LeagueCatcher
Herman Roth
Lost GenerationLouisianaThrows RightBats RightNorth AmericaMilwaukee BearsNegro National LeagueCatcher

On the career numbers, Herman Roth posted the stronger offensive profile against Ed McDonough. Herman Roth posted stronger numbers in OPS (.584 vs .200) and on-base percentage (.279 vs .100). By the career numbers, Herman Roth had the stronger overall case — though those totals don't account for the eras and run environments each player worked in.

Hitting Stats for Ed McDonough and Herman Roth

Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
2
2
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
3
3
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PAverified
6
360
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PA
89
182.88
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
10
600
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PA
292
600
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PAverified
10
600
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PA
272
558.9
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0.1
0.1
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.25
0.25
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0.2
0.2
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.61
0.61
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
1
60
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
68
139.73
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
1
60
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
58
119.18
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
7
14.38
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
1
2.05
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
2
4.11
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
10
20.55
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.147
0.147
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.007
0.007
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.029
0.029
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0.09
5.34
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
23.6
48.49
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
1
60
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
83
170.55
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
1
60
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
79
162.33
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0.1
0.1
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.279
0.279
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0.1
0.1
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.305
0.305
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0.2
0.2
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.584
0.584
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.055
0.055
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0.07
0.07
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.202
0.202
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0.111
0.111
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.471
0.471
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0.111
0.111
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.245
0.245
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PAverified
1
60
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PA
27
55.48
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
35
71.92
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
1
60
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
60
123.29
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
-0.33
-19.83
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
27.81
57.14
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
1
2.05
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
10
20.55
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
1
60
Herman Roth
Career
Per 600 PAverified
1
2.05
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
10
10
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
292
292
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
10
10
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
9
18.49
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
2
4.11
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
2
4.11
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 600 PA
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
100
100

Fielding Stats for Ed McDonough and Herman Roth

Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Innings
2
2
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
3
3
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
5
2.14
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
86
1.26
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Innings
2
0.86
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
73
1.07
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Innings
63
27
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
1844
27
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Innings
21
9
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
614.2
9
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
12
5.14
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
280
4.1
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Innings
2
0.86
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
79
1.16
Ed McDonough
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
0
0
Herman Roth
Career
Per 9 Innings
21
0.31
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
14
6
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
380
5.56
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
14
6
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
359
5.26
Ed McDonough
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
100
100
Herman Roth
Career
Per 9 Innings
94.47
94.47
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Innings
2.8
2.8
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
4.174
4.174
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Innings
40
40
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
84.88
84.88
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
0
Herman Roth
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
4
0.06
Ed McDonough
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
0
0
Herman Roth
Career
Per 9 Innings
3
0.04
Ed McDonough
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
0
Herman Roth
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
0
Ed McDonough
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
8
3.43
Herman Roth
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
58
0.85
Ed McDonough
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
2
0.86
Herman Roth
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
0