Joe McCarthy vs. Al Simmons — Career Comparison

Joe McCarthy
Pre-GenerationalNew YorkThrows RightBats RightNorth AmericaSt. Louis CardinalsNational LeagueCatcher
Al Simmons
Greatest GenerationWisconsinThrows RightBats RightNorth AmericaPhiladelphia AthleticsAmerican LeagueHall of FameLeft FielderAll-Star

On the career numbers, Al Simmons posted the stronger offensive profile against Joe McCarthy. Al Simmons posted stronger numbers in OPS (.915 vs .550) and on-base percentage (.380 vs .268). By the career numbers, Al Simmons had the stronger overall case — though those totals don't account for the eras and run environments each player worked in.

Hitting Stats for Joe McCarthy and Al Simmons

Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
2
2
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
20
20
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PAverified
16
234.15
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PA
2215
139.67
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
41
600
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PA
9515
600
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PAverified
39
570.73
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PA
8759
552.33
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.231
0.231
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.334
0.334
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.561
0.561
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.914
0.914
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
9
131.71
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
2927
184.57
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
7
102.44
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
1932
121.83
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
2
29.27
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
539
33.99
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
149
9.4
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
307
19.36
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
2
29.27
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
995
62.74
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.222
0.222
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.34
0.34
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.035
0.035
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.105
0.105
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
2.99
43.82
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
1688.59
106.48
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
11
160.98
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
4685
295.43
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
11
160.98
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
3572
225.24
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.268
0.268
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.38
0.38
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.282
0.282
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.535
0.535
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.55
0.55
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.915
0.915
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.051
0.051
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.201
0.201
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.191
0.191
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.305
0.305
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.433
0.433
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.915
0.915
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.265
0.265
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.34
0.34
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
3
43.9
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
1507
95.03
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
2
29.27
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
1827
115.21
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
5
73.17
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
3027
190.88
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
3.28
47.94
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
1801.22
113.58
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
30
1.89
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
2
29.27
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
615
38.78
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 600 PA
5
73.17
Al Simmons
Career
Per 600 PAverified
737
46.47
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
8.2
8.2
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
12.91
12.91
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0.4
0.4
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0.83
0.83
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
111
7
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
0
0
Al Simmons
Career
Per 600 PA
23
1.45
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
88
5.55
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
64
4.04
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
0
0
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
152
9.58
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 600 PA
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 600 PAverified
57.89
57.89

Fielding Stats for Joe McCarthy and Al Simmons

Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
2
2
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
20
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
16
1.58
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
2143
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
11
1.09
Al Simmons
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
273
27
Al Simmons
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
91
9
Al Simmons
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
49
4.85
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
5000
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
15
1.48
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
169
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
1
0.1
Al Simmons
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
94
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
65
6.43
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
5263
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
64
6.33
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
5169
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
98.46
98.46
Al Simmons
Career
Per 9 Innings
98.21
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
4
4
Al Simmons
Career
Per 9 Innings
2.412
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
68.75
68.75
Al Simmons
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Inningsverified
2
0.2
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 9 Innings
38
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Innings
5
0.49
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
0
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
0
Al Simmons
Career
Per 9 Innings
0
Joe McCarthy
Career
Per 9 Innings
17
1.68
Al Simmons
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
0
Joe McCarthy
Careerverified
Per 9 Inningsverified
11
1.09
Al Simmons
Career
Per 9 Innings
0