Jeff's Bespoke Baseball Stats

Brett Butler vs. Dave Collins — Career Comparison

Brett Butler

Baby BoomersCaliforniaThrows LeftBats LeftNorth AmericaLos Angeles DodgersNational LeagueCenter FielderAll-Star

Dave Collins

Baby BoomersSouth DakotaThrows LeftBats SwitchNorth AmericaCincinnati RedsNational LeagueLeft Fielder

When their careers are measured against the same standard, Brett Butler comes out clearly ahead of Dave Collins across most offensive categories. Brett Butler led in walk rate (BB%+ 154 vs 96), contact rate (K%+ 166 vs 116), and on-base percentage (OBP+ 121 vs 109). Brett Butler was the more complete offensive player.

Hitting Stats for Brett Butler and Dave Collins

Seasons Hitting

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

17

17

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

16

16

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

2213

139.11

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

1701

185.33

Plate Appearances

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

9545

600

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

5507

600

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

8180

514.2

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

4907

534.63

Batting Average

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.29

0.29

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.272

0.272

Equivalent Average

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.797

0.797

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.745

0.745

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

2375

149.29

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

1335

145.45

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

1913

120.25

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

1064

115.93

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

277

17.41

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

187

20.37

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

131

8.23

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

52

5.67

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

54

3.39

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

32

3.49

Extra Base Hits

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

462

29.04

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

271

29.53

Extra Base Hit Pct

Brett Butler

Career

Per 600 PA

0.195

0.195

Dave Collins

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.203

0.203

Home Runs Per at Bat

Brett Butler

Career

Per 600 PA

0.007

0.007

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.007

0.007

Home Runs Per Hit

Brett Butler

Career

Per 600 PA

0.023

0.023

Dave Collins

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.024

0.024

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

1292.33

81.24

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

643.51

70.11

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

3076

193.36

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

1722

187.62

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

3542

222.65

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

1840

200.47

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.377

0.377

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.338

0.338

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.376

0.376

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.351

0.351

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.753

0.753

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.689

0.689

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.086

0.086

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.079

0.079

Gross Production Average (GPA)

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.264

0.264

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.24

0.24

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.784

0.784

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.696

0.696

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.319

0.319

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.307

0.307

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

1359

85.43

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

667

72.67

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

578

36.33

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

373

40.64

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

1883

118.37

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

1008

109.82

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

1374.25

86.39

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

679.84

74.07

Brett Butler

Career

Per 600 PA

38

2.39

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

38

4.14

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

1129

70.97

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

467

50.88

Intentional Walks

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

23

1.45

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

16

1.74

Brett Butler

Career

Per 600 PAverified

907

57.01

Dave Collins

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

660

71.91

Plate Appearances per Strikeout

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

10.52

10.52

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

8.34

8.34

Walks Per Strikeout

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

1.24

1.24

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

0.71

0.71

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

147

9.24

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

64

6.97

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

51

3.21

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

31

3.38

Ground into Double Play (GIDP)

Brett Butler

Career

Per 600 PAverified

62

3.9

Dave Collins

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

59

6.43

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

558

35.08

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

395

43.04

Caught Stealing

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

257

16.16

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PA

139

15.14

Stolen Base Attempts

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

815

51.23

Dave Collins

Career

Per 600 PAverified

534

58.18

Stolen Base Percentage

Brett Butler

Career

Per 600 PA

68.47

68.47

Dave Collins

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

73.97

73.97

Fielding Stats for Brett Butler and Dave Collins

Seasons Fielding

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

17

17

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

16

16

Games Played as Fielder

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

2159

1.06

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Inningsverified

1243

1.21

Starts as Fielder

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

2080

1.02

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

1044

1.02

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

54791

27

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

27654

27

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

18263.2

9

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

9218

9

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

5296

2.61

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Inningsverified

2869

2.8

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

122

0.06

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Inningsverified

78

0.08

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

41

0.02

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

42

0.04

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

5459

2.69

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Inningsverified

2989

2.92

Chances Accepted

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

5418

2.67

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Inningsverified

2947

2.88

Fielding Percentage

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

99.25

99.25

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

98.59

98.59

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

2.51

2.51

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

2.371

2.371

Games Started %

Brett Butler

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

96.34

96.34

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

83.99

83.99

Brett Butler

Career

Per 9 Innings

32

0.02

Dave Collins

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

66

0.06

Brett Butler

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0

Wild Pitch as Fielder

Brett Butler

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0

Stolen Base Allowed

Brett Butler

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0

Catcher Caught Stealing

Brett Butler

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0

Dave Collins

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0