Jeff's Bespoke Baseball Stats

Toby Atwell vs. Carl Whitney — Career Comparison

Toby Atwell

Greatest GenerationVirginiaThrows RightBats LeftNorth AmericaPittsburgh PiratesNational LeagueCatcherAll-Star

Carl Whitney

Greatest GenerationMissouriThrows LeftBats LeftNorth AmericaNew York Black YankeesNegro National League IILeft Fielder

Looking at the career totals, Toby Atwell and Carl Whitney are closely matched on the surface stats. Carl Whitney posted stronger numbers in OPS (.733 vs .693) and slugging (.386 vs .333). Toby Atwell had the advantage in on-base percentage (.360 vs .346). By the career numbers, Carl Whitney had the stronger overall case — though those totals don't account for the eras and run environments each player worked in.

Hitting Stats for Toby Atwell and Carl Whitney

Seasons Hitting

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

5

5

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

1

1

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

378

173.93

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

15

173.08

Plate Appearances

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

1304

600

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

52

600

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

1117

513.96

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

44

507.69

Batting Average

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.26

0.26

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

0.227

0.227

Equivalent Average

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

0.716

0.716

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.764

0.764

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

290

133.44

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

10

115.38

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

233

107.21

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

6

69.23

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

41

18.87

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

2

23.08

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

7

3.22

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

1

11.54

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

9

4.14

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

1

11.54

Extra Base Hits

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

57

26.23

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

4

46.15

Extra Base Hit Pct

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

0.197

0.197

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.4

0.4

Home Runs Per at Bat

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

0.008

0.008

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.023

0.023

Home Runs Per Hit

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

0.031

0.031

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.1

0.1

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

135.06

62.14

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

6.81

78.52

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

372

171.17

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

17

196.15

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

459

211.2

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

18

207.69

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.355

0.355

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

0.346

0.346

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

0.333

0.333

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.386

0.386

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

0.688

0.688

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.733

0.733

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

0.073

0.073

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.159

0.159

Gross Production Average (GPA)

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

0.243

0.243

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.252

0.252

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

0.628

0.628

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.771

0.771

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0.273

0.273

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

0.22

0.22

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

116

53.37

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

9

103.85

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

110

50.61

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

3

34.62

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

217

99.85

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

11

126.92

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

150.65

69.32

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

6.79

78.29

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

8

3.68

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

0

0

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

161

74.08

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

8

92.31

Intentional Walks

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

10

4.6

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

0

0

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

84

38.65

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

2

23.08

Plate Appearances per Strikeout

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

15.52

15.52

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

26

26

Walks Per Strikeout

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

1.92

1.92

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

4

4

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

11

5.06

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

0

0

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

7

3.22

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PA

0

0

Ground into Double Play (GIDP)

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

36

16.56

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

0

0

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

4

1.84

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

2

23.08

Caught Stealing

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

5

2.3

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

1

11.54

Stolen Base Attempts

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 600 PA

9

4.14

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 600 PAverified

3

34.62

Stolen Base Percentage

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 600 PA

44.44

44.44

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 600 PAverified

66.67

66.67

Fielding Stats for Toby Atwell and Carl Whitney

Seasons Fielding

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

5

5

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

1

1

Games Played as Fielder

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

344

2.28

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

15

1.35

Starts as Fielder

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

156

1.04

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Inningsverified

13

1.17

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

4065

27

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

300

27

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Innings

1355

9

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

100

9

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

1499

9.96

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

13

1.17

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

156

1.04

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 9 Innings

34

0.23

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

2

0.18

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

1689

11.22

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

15

1.35

Chances Accepted

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

1655

10.99

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

13

1.17

Fielding Percentage

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

97.99

97.99

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

86.67

86.67

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

4.811

4.811

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

0.867

0.867

Games Started %

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 9 Innings

45.35

45.35

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

86.67

86.67

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

12

0.08

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 9 Innings

30

0.2

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

0

0

Wild Pitch as Fielder

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 9 Innings

17

0.11

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

0

0

Stolen Base Allowed

Toby Atwell

Career

Per 9 Innings

55

0.37

Carl Whitney

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

0

0

Catcher Caught Stealing

Toby Atwell

Careerverified

Per 9 Inningsverified

26

0.17

Carl Whitney

Career

Per 9 Innings

0

0