Who is the better baseball player Ed Donnelly or Tommy McCarthy? It is a simple question that does not always have a simple answer.
I assume that if you are here, you have questions about who is best in your match up or you need help changing someone's mind.
I can't guarantee it will work, but good luck nonetheless.
If you are less interested in a Ed Donnelly vs. Tommy McCarthy comparison and are more interested to see if one is tracking the other,
then you are in luck! Click the “View Charts” link in the stat box to see how they compare over their careers. The data
table and charts on these pages visualize how each player has progressed through their careers. They also summarizes both
players' career performance.
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Bats
Right
Right
Throws
Right
Right
Position
Relief Pitcher
Right Field
Generation
The Silent Generation
Pre-Generational
Hall of Fame
No
Yes
Pitching Stats for Ed Donnelly and Tommy McCarthy
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
6
1
Career
162 Game Avg.
9
68
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
13
68
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
7
0
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1
1
Tommy McCarthy
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
1
1
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
50
50
Tommy McCarthy
Career
162 Game Avg.
0
50
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
5
0
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
5
38
Career
162 Game Avg.
39
38
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
3.14
3.14
Career
162 Game Avg.
4.99
3.14
Career
162 Game Avg.
6.08
6.08
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
4.5
6.08
Career
162 Game Avg.
4.95
4.95
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
4.07
4.95
Career
162 Game Avg.
0.3
0.3
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.281
0.3
Career
162 Game Avg.
43
325
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
211
325
Career
162 Game Avg.
14.33
108.3
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
70.33
108.3
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
18
136
Career
162 Game Avg.
85
136
Career
162 Game Avg.
11.3
11.3
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
10.88
11.3
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
1
8
Career
162 Game Avg.
0.63
0.63
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.38
0.63
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
0.11
0.11
Career
162 Game Avg.
0.23
0.11
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
9
68
Career
162 Game Avg.
26
68
Tommy McCarthy
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0
8
Career
162 Game Avg.
5.65
5.65
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
3.33
5.65
Career
162 Game Avg.
6
45
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
21
45
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
3.77
3.77
Career
162 Game Avg.
2.69
3.77
Career
162 Game Avg.
0.67
0.67
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1.62
0.67
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1.047
1.047
Career
162 Game Avg.
0.668
1.047
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
0
0
Career
162 Game Avg.
12
0
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Tommy McCarthy
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0
8
Career
162 Game Avg.
69
521
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
328
521
Career
162 Game Avg.
3
23
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
7
23
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
7
53
Career
162 Game Avg.
65
53
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
4.4
4.4
Career
162 Game Avg.
8.32
4.4
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Career
162 Game Avg.
1.884
1.884
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1.578
1.884
Career
162 Game Avg.
60
453
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
302
453
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
0.78
0.78
Career
162 Game Avg.
5
0.78
Career
162 Game Avg.
0.315
0.315
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.292
0.315
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
43.33
43.33
Career
162 Game Avg.
41.97
43.33
Fielding Stats for Ed Donnelly and Tommy McCarthy
Career
162 Game Avg.
1
18
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
13
18
Career
162 Game Avg.
9
162
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1296
162
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Career
162 Game Avg.
43
774
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
33876
774
Career
162 Game Avg.
14.33
258
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
11292
258
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
2190
0
Career
162 Game Avg.
3
54
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
486
54
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
0
0
Career
162 Game Avg.
342
0
Career
162 Game Avg.
3
54
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
3018
54
Career
162 Game Avg.
3
54
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
2676
54
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
100
100
Career
162 Game Avg.
88.67
100
Career
162 Game Avg.
0.333
0.333
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
2.065
0.333
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
83
0
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Hitting Stats for Ed Donnelly and Tommy McCarthy
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
13
1
Career
162 Game Avg.
9
162
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1273
162
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
5739
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
5120
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.292
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.813
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1493
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1205
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
191
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
53
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
44
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
288
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.009
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.029
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
845.57
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1922
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
2079
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.362
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.375
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.738
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.084
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.257
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.821
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
0.296
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1066
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
732
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
1754
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
905.5
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
50
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
536
0
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.verified
0
0
Career
162 Game Avg.
185
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
31.02
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
2.9
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
33
0
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
468
0
Ed Donnelly
Tommy McCarthy
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
468
0
Ed Donnelly
Careerverified
162 Game Avg.
100
0